Critique for the StreetBeat:
Adi (MS Innovation leader):
- Our architecture ignores several obstacles: First and foremost, VANDALISM.
- Consider adding a WiFi connection
- Think about vandalism issues
- Our technological side must be emphasized and a complete tech EndToEnd scenraio should be defined
Spock
- We should know that playing just music from YouTube is not allowed (Ran already addressed this issue by suggesting SoundCloud)
Amiel:
- Our survey data is questionable
- We should look at Serendip: http://serendip.me/
application/login - We should not overlook "general" data (we're not planning to)
- The design is not very good; we should speak with Liat*
Itai:
- Our story is still rough
- We should look at TuneWiki: http://www.tunewiki.
com/ - We should think about starting event-based (like HashTagArt)**
Henit:
- Our experiment is not credible: we should look for problems when conducting an experiment
- Our differentiation is lacking in the sense that we didn't present a need that can't be better addressed in other manners -> We should try to position ourselves more precisely, when looking at the competition***
- We should also describe what happens "after" our current scenario; data-wise and user-wise; this should be added to the vision(?)
Guy:
- The pictures on the user survey didn't match the talk
Bottom line and next steps:
*We should ask to speak with Liat and consult about a better design. While we're at it, consult how to actually build it.
**We could start at a head-phone party, they have these at Dizegoff square every once in a while.
**We could start at a head-phone party, they have these at Dizegoff square every once in a while.
***Find a better way to show a competition slide that categorizes other products/services.
Now really, the bottom line: |
V
________________________________
V
________________________________
No comments:
Post a Comment